We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. Rankings are formula-based and never paid for. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure

Brother XP2 vs Pfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery Machine

Two machines whose official specification tables we used in this category. Rankings follow the printed formula; commissions never change the order.

Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never affects our rankings, which come from the published scoring formula. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

#2 of 50 in Embroidery and combo machines

Brother XP2

8.3/10

Best for: official field 10 5/8" x 16", 1322 official built-in designs, 824 official sewing stitches

Check price at Amazon
#4 of 50 in Embroidery and combo machines

Pfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery Machine

8.1/10

Best for: official field 450 x 450 mm, 920 official built-in designs, 870 official sewing stitches

Check price at Amazon

Spec-by-spec comparison

Green marks the better published figure. "Not listed" means the manufacturer doesn't publish it.

SpecBrother XP2Pfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery MachineWeight
Official embroidery area (computed)Official embroidery field width times official field height, in square inches. The product of those official figures is labelled computed. Millimetre-only official fields are converted to inches first. 170 sq in 314 sq in 30%
Official built-in embroidery designsThe official built-in embroidery design count on the maker's specification table. 1322 designs 920 designs 25%
Official maximum embroidery speedThe official maximum embroidery speed in stitches per minute. If the table omits embroidery speed, the field is Not listed and scores at the category minimum. We do not substitute sewing speed for embroidery speed. Not listed Not listed 25%
Official built-in sewing stitchesOfficial built-in sewing stitch count on combo machines. Embroidery-only machines often omit this field; it is then Not listed and scores at the category minimum. 824 stitches 870 stitches 20%
Official sewing space (specification table)5" x 13.1"12.1" (310 mm)info
Official embroidery field10 5/8" x 16"450 x 450 mminfo
Official embroidery area (computed)170.0 sq in (computed from official 10.625" × 16")314.0 sq in (computed from official 17.72" × 17.72", converted from official millimetres)info
Official machine weight43.21 lbNot listedinfo
Official needle threaderAutomaticAutomaticinfo
Official thread cutterYesAuto Snipinfo
Official unit dimensions27.16" x 12.67" x 13.74"Not listedinfo
Official displayLCDNot listedinfo
Official included accessory feet1/4" Foot , Camera Detecting Buttonhole Foot , Dual Feed (Digital Dual Feed) Foot , Straight Stitch Foot , Free-Motion Echo Quilting Foot , Button Fitting Foot , Couching Dual Feed Foot , Free-Motion Open Toe Quilting Foot , Zipper Foot , Overcasting Foot , Blindstich Foot , M…Not listedinfo
Official embroidery fonts24Not listedinfo
Official drop feedAutomaticNot listedinfo
Official warranty wording2/6/25 Year Premium Limited WarrantyNot listedinfo
Source noteOfficial work-space field lists 5" x 13.1"; we score the larger official dimension as sewing space to the right of the needle.Not listedinfo
Official screen sizeNot listed10.1" (257 mm)info
StitchPick score8.3/108.1/10100%

Where each one comes out ahead

Brother XP2

Better published figure on: Official built-in embroidery designs.

What we like

  • Official field computes to 170.0 sq in
  • Official table lists 1,322 built-in embroidery designs
  • Official table also lists 824 sewing stitches

Watch out for

  • Official table we used does not list a maximum embroidery speed

Pfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery Machine

Better published figure on: Official embroidery area (computed), Official built-in sewing stitches.

What we like

  • Official field computes to 314.0 sq in
  • Official table lists 920 built-in embroidery designs
  • Official table also lists 870 sewing stitches

Watch out for

  • Official table we used does not list a maximum embroidery speed

Verdict

Compare the official scored fields on each maker's specification table. Pfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery Machine and Brother XP2 differ on at least one official published figure.

Brother XP2 on AmazonPfaff Creative icon 3 Sewing & Embroidery Machine on Amazon
Spec sources

Related comparisons